More on Motor Oil Magnets

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Kirk Kohnen, Jul 27, 2003.

  1. Kirk Kohnen

    Kirk Kohnen Guest

    Hello all!

    (Oh, by the way, the post about the power steering fluid was a joke - let's
    see what kind of responses we get. Shhhhh..)

    I have an Ion 3 Quad Coupe. It has the 2.2 liter Ecotec engine with the
    in-block oil filter.

    I've been doing a little experiment. I put a Samarium Cobalt magnet in the
    area around the oil filter cartridge. (I chose this type of magnet because
    it is the second strongest type there is, but it is good to over 300 degrees
    C. The Neodymium magnets are stronger and cheaper, but they're only good to
    80 degrees C [I've seen ones that claim to be good to 150 degrees C, but it
    isn't at all clear how to determine which Neodymium alloy your magnet would
    have]).

    After a few thousand miles, I took the magnet out and rinsed it in mineral
    spirits (to remove the motor oil and not the swarf).

    I was left with a magnet that looked as if it had been painted a slightly
    darker shade than it originally was.

    After this, I let it dry and wiped it on some toilet paper. What I got is a
    piece of toilet paper that looks as if it was smudged with charcoal. And,
    the smudges are attracted to strong magnets.

    This is what I would expect. The fact that the filter removes the large
    particles leaves only the microscopic ones to be captured by the magnet.

    So, I think that I have a magnet in there that is truly attracting the small
    magnetic stuff. There is very little of it (only enough to smudge about a 2"
    diameter circle of toilet paper) but I figure that removing it has got to be
    better than letting it circulate.

    In the Ecotec engine, there is a niche in the area around the oil filter
    element that can easily accommodate a 1" x 1" x 3/8" Samarium Cobalt magnet.
    Maybe one of the performance shops (SPS?) might want to buy some of the
    SamCo magnets in bulk and sell them as oil magnets for the Ecotec 2.2 liter
    engine.

    I understand that the V6 also uses a similar oil filter scheme - maybe this
    trick can be done for it too?

    I'll let the group know more when I know more. - k.
     
    Kirk Kohnen, Jul 27, 2003
    #1
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.